Blake Lively is turning up the heat in her ongoing legal battle with Justin Baldoni. The Hollywood actress, known for her roles in Gossip Girl and A Simple Favor, has taken drastic legal steps to uncover what she claims is a coordinated smear campaign against her.
The 37-year-old star is demanding phone records from Baldoni, his associates, and his crisis management team in an effort to prove that he orchestrated a retaliation effort after she accused him of sexual harassment. Lively’s legal team believes that these records could provide undeniable evidence of a plan to damage her career and reputation.
This escalating dispute, which began in December 2024, has since turned into a high-profile courtroom showdown. Baldoni, best known for his role in Jane the Virgin, has fiercely denied Lively’s allegations and has responded with a staggering $400 million countersuit against her, her husband Ryan Reynolds, and her longtime publicist Leslie Sloane.
The case has captivated Hollywood, with both sides aggressively pushing their legal strategies. Lively is not backing down, and her team’s latest subpoenas could change the course of the legal fight entirely.
Hollywood Drama Unfolds as Lively Seeks Key Evidence
Lively’s legal team, led by attorneys Mike Gottlieb and Esra Hudson, recently issued subpoenas for phone records from major service providers, including AT&T, Verizon, and T-Mobile. These subpoenas specifically target Baldoni, his close associates, and his crisis consultants, including Jennifer Abel and Melissa Nathan.
In addition to phone records, Lively’s team is also seeking internet activity logs from companies such as Cloudflare and AOL. They believe these digital footprints could help trace the origins of the alleged smear campaign.
A spokesperson for Lively emphasized that these records are critical in exposing the full scope of what they call a “retaliation plan” aimed at tarnishing her reputation.
Lively’s decision to go after Baldoni’s communications has raised eyebrows in the entertainment industry, with many speculating about what she might uncover. The actress remains confident that these records will validate her claims and provide the necessary proof to support her legal fight.
Blake Lively vs. Justin Baldoni: The Legal War Intensifies
The legal battle between Lively and Baldoni began after Lively accused Baldoni of sexual harassment during the filming of It Ends With Us. The actress claims that when she spoke out, Baldoni and his PR team launched a strategic campaign to discredit her.
In response, Baldoni filed his own lawsuit, alleging that Lively and her team engaged in civil extortion and defamation. His attorney, Bryan Freedman, dismissed Lively’s subpoenas as an “extraordinary fishing expedition,” calling her allegations “provably false.”
While Baldoni denies any wrongdoing, Lively’s legal team is determined to uncover the truth. They have also turned their attention to crisis consultant Jed Wallace, who they suspect played a role in the alleged campaign against her. Wallace, whose firm Street Relations was named in the subpoenas, has since filed a separate defamation lawsuit against Lively.
Despite these legal counterattacks, Lively remains focused on exposing what she claims is a deliberate effort to ruin her career. Her team insists that the phone and internet records will reveal key details about the extent of the alleged retaliation.
Blake Lively’s Fight for Justice Gains Public Attention
The legal battle has sparked intense public discussion, with fans and legal experts alike weighing in on the high-profile case. Many have compared Lively’s situation to other Hollywood power struggles, where accusations of misconduct are often followed by aggressive PR campaigns to discredit the accuser.
Lively’s supporters believe her determination to uncover the truth shows her commitment to holding powerful figures accountable. A source close to the actress said that she is prepared for a long legal fight, but she remains confident that justice will prevail.
“Blake Lively is not someone who backs down easily,” the source said. “She has the resources, the evidence, and the legal team to fight this battle all the way.”
What’s Next for Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni?
As the case heads toward trial in March 2026, both sides are intensifying their legal strategies. Lively’s team continues to push for more subpoenas, determined to uncover every possible detail about the alleged smear campaign.
Baldoni, on the other hand, is standing firm in his defense. His team has vowed to fight back against what they call a “baseless” attack on his reputation.
With new developments emerging regularly, Hollywood is watching closely to see how this legal showdown unfolds. Whether Lively’s subpoenas will reveal the evidence she needs remains to be seen, but one thing is certain—this battle is far from over.
As Lively fights to clear her name, the entertainment world braces for what could be one of the most explosive Hollywood legal battles in recent years.
Jaja has a degree in journalism and took classes in international law and business communication. Jaja’s career spans roles at prominent international media outlets, including Business Times and Brigada. As a news editor, she covered a wide range of beats, including business, economy, cryptocurrency, and personal finance. Additionally, she has successfully managed teams of writers producing content on gaming, technology, and entertainment.
Discover more from Today's Esquire
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.